Elroy appears in U.S. registration data going all the way back to 1880, when records begin. Its popularity climbed over the following decades. In 1922, 192 babies received the name (ranked #438). Today it sits well outside the top 1,000 (around #4445), with roughly 23 babies named Elroy each year. Elroy's usage has held roughly steady recently. In total, around 7,460 babies have been registered with this name since 1880.